Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Bruschetta With Toasted Bread Points
Bottled Water
Chocolate Mousse Cup
Freshly Baked Cookie
About
Fentoni's Pizza
Nestled along the picturesque Carolina Beach, Fentoni's Pizza emerges as a beacon for pizza aficionados and families alike. Known for its light and crisp crust, Fentoni's has quickly become a beloved local spot, drawing praise from enthusiastic customers. Their address at 1018 N Lake Park Blvd, Carolina Beach, NC 28428 positions them perfectly for beachgoers seeking a delicious respite.
Customers rave about the generous, floppy slices, rich with cheese and balanced sauce that keeps each bite a delight. The accompanying garlic knots have also garnered admiration, proving to be a perfect side for sharing. As Allie Pyles notes, the engaging staff adds a personal touch, with friendly service enhancing the relaxed atmosphere. Many families find solace in Fentoni's after navigating the often bustling boardwalk environment.
On a busy Friday evening, the energy inside is palpable, echoing the lively spirit of the Carolina Beach community. Jeremiah Quarles captures this feeling, highlighting the fast service and great tasting pizza that resonates perfectly with visitors enjoying a beach getaway. The quality to price ratio is commendable, making Fentoni's an attractive option for those looking to indulge without breaking the bank.
Testimonials paint a glowing picture of Fentoni's, with Mary Jo indicating it's her go-to for delivery, citing their pizza as the best she’s tried in over fifty years! This dedication to flavor is further complemented by their other offerings, such as the boneless mild wings, which are lightly seasoned to perfection.
Families are not just customers here; they are treated like family. The warm ambiance and inviting staff create a sense of belonging, making every visit a pleasant experience. With glowing reviews, including shout-outs to the dedicated staff members like Matt and Van, it’s clear that Fentoni's Pizza is more than just a meal—it’s a community destination.
If you're in the Carolina Beach area seeking delicious, high-quality pizza with a friendly touch, stop by Fentoni's Pizza. Whether you're dining in, grabbing a slice on the go, or ordering for a cozy night in, Fentoni's promises to deliver delightful flavors and unforgettable experiences.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Great pizza, light and crisp. Wasn’t hot when I got home (less than 10 min drive) so not sure if they keep it warm enough after cooking but maybe it was just a 1 time thing. We’ll be back ”
“ Pizza was delicious! I love a good, floppy slice with lots of cheese and not too much sauce. We also had an order of garlic knots to share which were quite tasty. Service was excellent and our kids were amazed by the 80 lb batch of dough the team was dividing. The guy who took our order was super friendly and engaging telling us about the process. A note to families on the atmosphere- could have been the time of year/day we stopped in. The boardwalk at Carolina Beach was a tad unsavory for us. We're not uptight, stick in the butt kind but there were folks stumbling around during the middle of the day and glassy eyes. No danger, just not the place we choose to have our young kids if possible. Fentoni's was a little haven after we'd accidentally strolled into a couple different bars with our kids in tow. ”
“ Place was packed on a Friday evening. 7 or so kids slinging pizza, and food was ready when estimated. Pizza was great, service was good. I'm usually critical of the quality to price ratio when eating out at the beach: no complaints here. ”
“ Great neighborhood pizza by the slice place! Meatballs are delicious too! They treat you like family! 10 out of 10 and a shout out to Matt and Van for always being so awesome! ”
“ This is the third time I ordered for delivery which was super fast. The pizza is the best I have ever tasted or tried and I have tried many over the past 50 years. Thank you for making the best pizza!! The boneless mild wings were also delicious and lightly seasoned. ”
“ We were stressing about having some good pizza... Got on the googles and found a few places. We took a look at their menu and got the fried ravioli and a buffalo chicken pizza... Walking in the door, it's a youthful atmosphere and if the kids keep working on schmoozing with the customers, they have gold happening. One noticed the designs on our T-shirts and helped us out with extras like forks and such. He also made a point to say he'd just pulled our pizza from the oven upon hearing our name. The fried ravioli is amazing! When we took our first bites of the pizza... The first words out of my husband were: "Wow! This is amazing!" Y'all definitely need to get your pizza from Fentoni's! ”
“ This pizza is amazing, and the Ravioli were as well. Delivery was spot on. Warm and delicious.Thank you for a fantastic first meal at Carolina Beach. We will definitely be back. ”
“ This is a great little pizza place, Matthew and his staff are awesome. The pizza is superb,had a slice of the Sicilian pepperoni....outstanding. Stop by and check them out, you won’t be disappointed. ”